Conventional debt securities require the payment of capital on a fixed date and carry interest at an arm-length rate. On the other hand, conventional equity instruments give the investor the right to participate in the profits of the underlying transaction, but are not allowed to withdraw the investments made to acquire the instrument; On the contrary, the investment is subject to the risks of the company. Many instruments bear both debt and equity. For example, convertible bonds may, in certain circumstances, be considered equity.4 It seems clear, however, that a SAFE should not be considered a debt for income tax purposes in the United States. this is consistent with Y-Combinator`s original intention to create SAFE as an alternative to converting debt.5 LC who have not chosen to be taxed as C-capital companies are taxed as partnerships, or companies go through companies for federal tax purposes in the United States. FASD should be considered as “non-compensatory” (non-commissioned) options for tax purposes in partnership. U.S. financial rules define non-compensatory options to “include a contractual right to acquire a stake in the issuer partnership with options other than those issued in relation to service delivery.” However, there is no definitive irS authority on this position. If the IRS were found to be non-commissioned NSSS, this could result in uncertain treatment, including the possibility that the IRS could treat the SAFE investor as a member of the LLC resulting from the safe distribution. This treatment would be supported by Article 5, point (c), of SAFE, which states that the holder of SAFE is fiscally the owner of the company`s capital and is entitled to the same dividends as those payable on the company`s common capital. Where there is a liquidity event prior to the safe conversion, the investor can often receive a cash payment equal to the safe purchase price (reduced if there is not enough cash to pay all investors) or equity.
If the entity dissolves while SAFE is pending, the entity will return the investor`s purchase price (reduced if the assets cannot support full repayment to creditors and investors – probably the SAFes will come after the debt and before the shareholders, although this may also be an open issue). As a result, SAFE holders appear to be largely on the rise, as they will likely dampen their investments in the company in a downward scenario and will not have rights as creditors. Since the characteristics of a “SAFE” differ from those of the more traditional debt and participation shares, the tax treatment of a SAFE may not be clear. There are a few details that all SAFE owners should know: Y Combinator published the Simple Agreement for Future Equity (“SAFE” investment instrument at the end of 2013 as an alternative to convertible debt.  This investment vehicle is now known in the U.S. and Canada because of its simplicity and low transaction costs. However, as use is increasingly frequent, concerns have arisen about its potential impact on entrepreneurs, particularly where several SAFE investment cycles take place prior to a private equity cycle and potential risks to un accredited crowdfunding investors who could invest in the SAFes of companies that realistically, never receive venture capital financing and therefore never convert to equity.  In a futures contract, one party agrees to acquire a fixed amount of assets from the other party at a fixed price on a fixed date. Legally, it is a bilateral enforcement contract. The forward buyer is betting that the price of the underlying property is increasing and that the forward seller is betting that it is falling.